57 West 57th St, New York, NY 10019 212.390.1111
57 West 57th St, New York, NY 10019 212.390.1111
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

a bowl filled with different types of food on a table
a bowl filled with different types of food on a table
Download PDF

Cocktails

  • Tricolore Margarita

    Tricolore Margarita

    Dobel Diamante Cristalino, Fresh Lime, Calabrian Chili-Infused Honey, Tricolore Cube

    $20

  • Quality Mule

    Grey Goose Vodka, Fresh Ginger, S. Pellegrino

    $19

  • A Midtown

    Maker's Mark, Housemade Vermouth, Burnt Sugar & Sour Cherry

    $18

  • Nitro Negroni

    Campari Negroni served from a Stout Tap

    $17

  • The 57 Spritz

    Aperol, Fresh-Pressed Grapefruit, Pomegranate

    $19

For the Table

  • Whipped Ricotta

    Pine Nuts, Honey

    $21

Crudi

  • Yellowtail

    Sorrento Lemon, Pistachio, Thai Basil

    $24

  • Scallop

    Soppressata, Pickled Serrano

    $19

  • Salmon

    Orange, Fennel, Chili

    $23

  • Tuna & Avocado Carpaccio

    Crispy Garlic Gremolata

    $28

Cocktails

  • U7 Shrimp

    U7 Shrimp

    23/29

  • Dressed Big Rock Oysters

    Aperol-Grapefruit Granita

    $5 per piece

  • Our Shellfish Tower

    Cracked Maine Lobster, Dressed Oysters, King Crab, U7 Shrimp, Tuna Crudo, Ostera Caviar

    MKT

Salads

  • Baby Kale Tricolore Salad

    $17

  • Beefsteak Tomato & Stracciatella

    $23

  • Little Gem Caesar

    $21

  • NY Chopped Salad

    $22

Appetizers

  • Elevation Meats Spicy Coppa

    $16

  • Tanara 24-Month Prosciutto di Parma

    $24

  • QI Baked Clams

    $23

  • Sausage & Pepper Garlic Toast

    $21

  • Grilled Octopus

    $28

  • Crispy Calamari Casino

    $23

  • Lobster Scampi Toast

    Fresh Maine Lobster, Smoked Tomato Butter

    $38

Housemade Pasta

Handmade Daily
  • Paccheri Amatriciana

    Paccheri Amatriciana

    Guanciale, Tomato, Pecorino

    $29

  • Pesto Mafaldine

    Broccoli Rabe, Pistachio, Sweet Italian Sausage

    $32

  • Black Truffle Cacio e Pepe

    Fresh Pappardelle, Pecorino

    $45

  • Potato & Robiola Gnocchi

    Melted Leeks, Chive Buds

    $29

  • Dry-Aged Porterhouse Agnolotti

    24 Month Parmesan, Brown Butter, Vincotto

    $44

  • Spicy Lobster Rigatoni Alla Vodka

    Whole Lobster, Calabrian Chili

    $53

  • Fusilli Al Manzo

    Filet Mignon Ragu, Chili Breadcrumbs, Basil

    $34

Bistecca

  • Classic Filet Mignon

    Classic Filet Mignon

    $64

  • Hanger Steak alla Griglia

    $45

  • NY Strip Steak

    $59

  • Bone-in Dry-Aged Prime Sirloin

    $74

  • Filet Au Chianti-Poivre

    $66

  • Add Tableside Truffle Butter Service

    + $9

Chicken Parm For Two

  • The Classic

    The Classic

    Chili Honey House Seasonings

    $86

  • Fra Diavolo Chicken Parm

    Calabrian Chili Tomato Sauce, Spicy Soppressata, Hot Cherry Peppers, Parmesan

    $90

Carne E Pesce

  • Lemon-Charred Chicken Alan

    Bitter Greens, Cured Lemons

    $39

  • Mediterranean Branzino

    Dressed Tomatoes, Crispy Shallot, Pistachio

    $48

  • Veal Milanese

    Cherry Pepper Tomatoes, Stracchino

    $49

  • Faroe Island Salmon

    Pesto Rosso

    $46

  • Berkshire Pork Chop

    Cherry Saba, Crispy Sage

    $38

  • Dover Sole

    Cured Lemons, Hazelnut Brown Butter

    $64

Sides

  • Broccoli Rabe

    Simply Grilled with Olive Oil

    $15

  • Baby Spinach

    Sautéed with Garlic

    $15

  • Crispy Brussels Sprouts

    Spicy Agrodulce

    $17

  • QI Tuscan Fries

    Parmesan Aioli

    $16

  • Corn Crème Brûlée

    A Quality Classic

    $17

  • Filet Mignon Meatballs

    House Special

    $23

  • Grilled Garlic Mushrooms

    $16

Download PDF

For the Table

  • Whipped Ricotta

    Pine Nuts, Honey

    $21

Appetizers

  • Dressed Big Rock Oysters

    Aperol-Grapefruit Granita

    $5 per pc

  • Tuna & Avocado Carpaccio

    Crispy Garlic Gremolata

    $28

  • Salmon

    Orange, Fennel, Chili

    $23

  • Yellowtail

    Sorrento Lemon, Pistachio, Thai Basil

    $24

  • U7 Shrimp Cocktail

    23/29

  • Little Gem Caesar

    $21

  • Beefsteak Tomato & Stracciatella

    $23

  • Filet Mignon Meatballs

    $23

  • Baby Kale Tricolore Salad

    $17

  • Crispy Calamari Casino

    $23

  • Our Shellfish Tower

    Cracked Maine Lobster, Dressed Oysters, King Crab, U7 Shrimp, Tuna Crudo, Ostera Caviar

    MKT

Pesce E Carne

  • The QI Burger

    $28

  • Faroe Island Salmon

    Pesto Rosso

    $46

  • Grilled Branzino

    Dressed Tomatoes, Crispy Shallot, Pistachio

    $48

  • Lemon-Charred Chicken Alan

    $39

Housemade Pasta

  • Potato & Robiola Gnocchi

    Melted Leeks, Chive Buds

    $29

  • Pesto Mafaldine

    Broccoli Rabe, Pistachio, Sweet Italian Sausage

    $32

  • Black Truffle Cacio e Pepe

    Fresh Pappardelle, Pecorino

    $45

  • Paccheri Amatriciana

    Guanciale, Tomato, Pecorino

    $29

  • Dry-Aged Porterhouse Agnolotti

    24 Month Parmesan, Brown Butter Vincotto

    $44

  • Spicy Lobster Rigatoni alla Vodka

    Whole Lobster, Calabrian Chili

    $53

  • Fusilli Al Manzo

    Filet Mignon Ragu, Chili Breadcrumbs, Basil

    $34

Bistecca

  • Classic Filet Mignon

    $64

  • Hanger Steak Alla Griglia

    $45

  • NY Strip Steak

    $59

  • Bone-In Dry-Aged Prime Sirloin

    $74

The Chopped

  • Roman

    Romaine, Parmesan, Cured Lemons, Sesame Breadcrumbs, Caesar Dressing

    $24

  • Tuscan

    Baby Spinach, Treviso, Gorgonzola, Marinated Artichokes, Crispy Pancetta, Pears, Candied Walnuts, Sherry-Saba Vinaigrette

    $22

  • Campania

    Heirloom Tomatoes, Arugula, Fennel, Oven-Dried Tomatoes, Pickled Onions, White Balsamic Dressing

    $25

  • New York

    Chopped Romaine, Charred Peppers, Cannellini, Pickled Mushrooms, Hardboiled Egg, Pepperoni, Olives, Sweet Oregano Vinaigrette

    $26

  • FINISHING TOUCH:

    Avocado or Burrata $6

    Grilled Chicken $10

    Pepper Seared Filet Mignon $15

    Seared Yellowfin Tuna $15

    Whole Maine Lobster $25

Chicken Parm Pizza For Two

  • The Classic

    Chili Honey, House Seasonings

    $86

Sides

$14

  • QI Tuscan Fries

  • Corn Crème Brûlée

  • Grilled Broccoli Rabe

  • Brussels Sprouts Calabrese

  • Sautéed Spinach

Desserts

  • Ferrero Rocher

    Milk Chocolate Hazelnut Cream

    $12

  • Salty Pistachio

    Sour Cherries, Pizzelle Cookie

    $12

  • Burnt Marshmallow

    Graham Cracker Pizzelle, Toasted Meringue

    $12

  • Chocolate Olive Oil Cake

    Cherry Compote, Espresso Nibs, Gelato

    $21

  • Tiramisu Luci

    Marscapone Cream

    $18

Download PDF

Sparkling

  • Tullia Prosecco NV Spumante

    Veneto

    $17

  • Perrier-Jouët NV Brut Champagne, France

    Champagne

    $29

White

  • Caposaldo 2023 Pinot Grigio

    Veneto

    $17

  • Sartarelli 2023 Verdicchio dei Castello di Jesi

    Le Marche

    $18

  • RouteStock 2023 Chardonnay

    Sonoma Coast

    $19

  • Fessina “Erse” 2023 Etna Bianco

    Sicily

    $19

  • Lilou 2023 Sauvignon Blanc

    Loire Valley

    $20

  • Flowers 2023 Chardonnay

    Sonoma Coast

    $26

Rosé

  • Sainte Marguerite “Symphonie” 2023 Côtes de Provence Rosé

    Provence

    $19

Red

  • Ronchi di Cialla "Ri-Nera" 2022 Schioppettino (served chilled)

    Friuli

    $17

  • Fèlsina 2022 Chianti Classico

    Tuscany

    $18

  • Quality Wine 2023 Cabernet Sauvignon

    California

    $19

  • Benton Lane 2022 Pinot Noir

    Willamette Valley

    $23

  • Antinori-Guado al Tasso “Il Bruciato” 2022 Bolgheri

    Tuscany

    $24

  • Gianfranco Alessandria 2020 Barolo

    Piedmont

    $26

  • Faust 2022 Cabernet Sauvignon

    Napa Valley

    $35

Download PDF

Hand Crafted Cocktails

Cocktails at Quality Italian are created by Head Barman Bryan Schneider, a veteran of several top cocktail dens including Monkey Bar and Brooklyn’s Clover Club.

  • Quality Mule

    Grey Goose, Fresh Ginger, S. Pellegrino

    $20

  • A Midtown

    Maker’s Mark, House Vermouth, Burnt Sugar & Sour Cherry

    $19

  • Tricolore Margarita

    Dobel Diamante Cristalino, Cointreau, Calabrian Chili-Infused Honey, Tricolore Cube

    $22

  • Nitro Negroni

    Campari Negroni served from a Stout Tap

    $18

  • The 57 Spritz

    Aperol, Fresh-Pressed Grapefruit, Pomegranate

    $20

  • Pocket Dial

    Ketel One, St. Germain, Cucumber & Basil

    $19

  • Mezcalero

    Ilegal Mezcal, Passion Fruit, Hazelnut, Chili, Lime

    $21

Zero Proof

  • Ginger Zinger

    Lemon, Ginger, Honey, Calabrian Chili

    $16

  • Falso Spritz

    St. Agrestis Amaro Falso, Blood Orange, San Pellegrino

    $15

  • Espresso Shakerato

    Espresso, Demerara, Yucca, Shaken

    $11

  • Phony Negroni

    St. Agrestis Brooklyn

    $14

  • Yamile "Sparkling Rosé"

    Muri, Copenhagen

    $17

  • Upside Dawn Golden Lager

    Athletic Brewing, Connecticut

    $8

Beer

  • Amstel Light Lager

    Zoeterwoude, Netherlands

    $9

  • Peroni Lager

    Rome, Italy

    $9

  • Athletic "Upside Dawn" N/A

    Milford, Connecticut

    $8

  • Graft "Farm Flor" Cider

    Newburg, New York

    $10

  • Three’s Brewing “Logical Conclusion” IPA

    Brooklyn, New York

    $11

  • Left Hand "Nitro" Milk Stout

    Longmont, Colorado

    $10

Download PDF

Dolce

  • Tiramisu Luci

    Tiramisu Luci

    Espresso-Soaked Almond Sponge, Mascarpone Cream

    $18

  • Chocolate Olive Oil Cake

    Cherry Compote, Espresso Nib Streusel, Gelato

    $19

  • Sticky Toffee Pudding

    Warm Toffee, Amaretto Crunch, Malted Vanilla Gelato

    $15

  • The Godfather

    Cannoli Cream, Gelato, Raspberry Compote, Espresso Nib Streusel, Sicilian Pistachios

    $23

'Cellos

12

  • Meyer Lemon

  • Key Lime & Basil Creamcello

  • Clementine & Elderflower

Gelato

12

  • Salty Pistachio

    Sour Cherries, Pizzelle Cookie

  • Ferrero Rocher

    Milk Chocolate Hazelnut Cream, Candied Hazelnuts

  • Burnt Marshmallow

    Graham Cracker Pizzelle, Toasted Meringue

  • Blood Orange Creamsicle

    Blood Orange Segments, Orange Chips

  • Lemon Sorbetto

    Candied Sorrento Lemons, Vanilla Bean

Housemade After Dinners

  • Corrected Grappa

    Espresso Distilled Grappa

    $15

  • Dry-Infused Sambuca

    Made In House with Our Signature Dry Infusion Process

    $15

  • Our Espresso Martini

    Grey Goose, Cold Brew Liqueur, Giffard Cacao

    $20

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Reservations

Please check errors in the form above
Thanks!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.