Quality Italian New York City Menu
At Quality Italian, our Prime beef is dry-aged for 28 days, butchered to our specifications, and brushed with olive oil and herbs.
Download PDFFOR THE TABLE
-
Quality Chicken Parm
Family Style, House Toppings
$68
-
Casella's Prosciutto Speciale, Hurleyville, NY
$24
-
Elevation Meats Fennel Pollen Salami
Denver, CO
$21
-
Housemade Battenkill Ricotta
Sicilian Oregano Flower Honey & Pine Nuts
$17
-
Our Signature Guac Genovese
Avocado & Pistachio Pesto
$22
COCKTAILS & RAW BAR
-
Cracked Lobster
$28
-
U7 Shrimp
$24
-
East & West Oysters
6pc $21
-
Shellfish Bouquets
$65
$125
CRUDO
-
Scallop
Squash Blossoms, Spiced Hazelnut, Lime
$21
-
Tuna
Beets, Avocado, Sicilian Pistachio
$23
-
Yellowtail
Salami Vinaigrette, Muffaletta
$19
APPETIZERS
-
Crispy Calamari Casino
Bacon, Peperoncini, Pimenton
$21
-
Spicy Crab Panzanella
Marinated Tomatoes, Garlic Croutons
$23
-
Sausage & Pepper Garlic-Toast
$19
-
QI Baked Clams
$21
-
Eggplant Polpette
Burrata, Pistachio Tomatoes
$18
PASTA FRESCA
HANDMADE IN HOUSE-
Bucatini & Clams
Pepperoni Ragu, Shishito, Crispy Potato
$32
-
Dry-Aged Porterhouse Agnolotti
$35
-
Corn Gnudi
Pistachio, Pecorino, Basil
$29
-
Garganelli Amatriciana
Guanciale, Tomato, Pecorino
$34
-
Spicy Lobster Rigatoni alla Vodka
$48
SALADS
-
Baby Kale Tricolore Salad
$13
-
Little Gem Caesar
$16
-
Beefsteak Tomato & Stracciatella
$18
-
NY Italian Chopped Salad
$17
QI BISTECCA
-
Dry Aged Bone-In Sirloin
$58
-
Dry Aged Tomahawk Ribsteak
$62
-
Skirt Steak alla Griglia
$39
-
Classic 10oz Filet
$49
THE FISH
-
Grilled Branzino
Caper-Marinated Tomatoes, Pistachio Pesto, Thai Basil
$42
-
Mediterranean Octopus
Gigante Beans, Capocollo, Castelfranco
$38
-
Dover Sole
Hazelnut Brown Butter
$54
The MEAT
-
Berkshire Pork Chop
Cherry Saba & Crispy Sage
$38
-
Veal Chop Milanese
House Pickled Peppers & Mozzarella
$49
-
Lamb Chops Scottadito
Farro Verde, Labneh & Mint
$47
-
Lemon-Charred Chicken Alan
$29
OLD SCHOOL FOR TWO
-
Short Rib Osso Buco
Leftover Polenta Pasta, Crispy Garlic Gremolata
$55 per person
-
Dry-Aged Porterhouse all Fiorentina
$60 per person
SIDES
$13-
Verdure
Grilled Broccoli Rabe • Sautéed Spinach • Roasted Asparagus
-
The New Classics
Brussels Sprouts Calabrese • Corn Crème Brûlée • Grilled Garlic Mushrooms
-
Roots & Grains
QI Tuscan Fries • Parmesan Fingerlings • Baked Manicotti
We have chosen some of New York’s oldest and most respected butchers to hand-select and cut our meats to our exacting specifications.
Download PDFFOR THE TABLE
Served with our Sesame Focaccia-
House-Made Battenkill Ricotta
Sicilian Oregano Flower Honey & Pine Nuts
$17
-
Our Signature Guac Genovese
Avocado & Pistachio Pesto
$22
-
Casella’s Proscuitto Speciale
Hurleyville, New York
$24
CRUDO
-
Scallop
Squash Blossoms, Spiced Hazelnut, Lime
$21
-
Tuna
Beets, Avocado, Sicilian Pistachio
$23
-
Yellowtail
Salami Vinaigrette, Muffaletta
$19
APPETIZERS
-
U7 Shrimp Cocktail
$23
$19
-
Cracked Lobster Cocktail
$18
-
East & West Coast Oysters
6pc $21
-
Baby Kale Tricolore Salad
$13
-
Little Gem Caesar
$16
-
Sausage & Pepper Garlic Toast
$19
-
Crispy Calamari Casino
Bacon, Peperoncini, Pimenton
$21
The Chopped
Select a mix:-
Roman:
Romaine, Parmesan, Cured Lemons, Sesame Breadcrumbs, Caesar Dressing
-
Tuscan:
Baby Spinach, Treviso, Gorgonzola, Marinated Artichokes, Crispy Pancetta, Pears, Candied Walnuts, Sherry-Saba Vinaigrette
-
Campania:
Heirloom Tomatoes, Arugula, Fennel, Oven-Dried Tomatoes, Pickled Onions, White Balsamic Dressing
-
New York:
Chopped Romaine, Charred Peppers, Cannellini, Pickled Mushrooms, Hardboiled Egg, Pepperoni, Olives, Sweet Oregano Vinaigrette
& A Finishing Touch:
-
The Classic
$19
-
Grilled Chicken Breast
$21
-
QI Shrimp Scampi
$24
-
Seared Yellowfin Tuna
$26
-
Grilled Calamari
$23
-
Pepper Seared Filet Mignon
$27
-
Spicy Lobster Salad
$31
QI Classics
-
Filet Mignon (10oz)
$49
-
Aged Bone-in Sirloin (18oz)
$58
-
QI Rib Steak (24oz)
$62
-
Lemon-Charred Chicken Alan
$29
-
Skirt Steak Alla Griglia
$39
The Sandwiches
-
Fra Diavolo Lobster Roll
$25
-
The QI Burger
$19
The Sea
-
Grilled Branzino
Caper-Marinated Tomatoes, Crispy Onions, Thai Basil
$42
-
Mediterranean Octopus
Gigante Beans, Capocollo, Castelfranco
$38
-
Seared Diver Scallops
Sicilian Red Pesto, Toasted Almonds, Endive
$29
Pasta Fresca
-
Bucatini & Clams
Pepperoni Ragu, Shishito, Crispy Potato
$32
-
Corn Gnudi
Pistachio, Pecorino, Basil
$29
-
Veal Piccata Pappardelle
Lemon & Capers
$33
Sides $13
-
Tuscan Fries
-
Corn Crème Brûlée
-
Grilled Broccoli Rabe
-
Brussels Sprouts Calabrese
-
Sautéed Spinach
Gelato
-
A dressed up Scoop To go
$9
-
By The Pint
$10
-
Humour Me Strawberry Shortcake
Piña Colada
Ferrero Rocher
Burnt Marshmallow Stracciatella
Agua Fresca
Dolce $12
-
The Hazelnut S’More
-
Apricot Semifreddo
-
Seasonal Berries
BOTTOMLESS BELINI CART $18
BLOODY MARYS $14
-
Classic
Spicy San Marzano Tomatoes
-
The Dry-Aged
Bloody Dry-Aged Fat-Washed Vodka
-
The Maria Capri
Heirloom Cherry Tomatoes & White Balsamic
APPETIZERS
-
U7 Shrimp Cocktail
$24
-
East & West Coast Oysters
6pc $21
-
Tuna Crudo
Beets, Avocado, Sicilian Pistachio
$23
-
Sausage & Pepper Garlic Toast
$19
-
Baby Kale Tricolore Salad
$13
-
Little Gem Caesar Salad
w/ Grilled Chicken +$5, w/ Shrimp Scampi +$7, w/ Grilled Calamari +$8
$16
BRUNCH CLASSICS
-
Polenta Pancakes
Blueberry Compote. Lemon Ricotta Cream
$17
-
Housemade Granola
Seasonal Fruit & Greek Yogurt
$14
-
Bananas Foster French Toast
Nutella Spread, Candied Hazelnuts
$19
-
Eggplant Parm Benedict
San Marzano Tomato, Pine Nuts, Basil Hollandaise
$17
-
Toad-in-the-Hole
Crispy Polenta, Fontina, Pears
$18
-
Baked Egg White Frittata
Market Vegetables
$16
-
Breakfast Risotto
Mortadella, Pistachio, Sunny-Side-Up-Egg
$23
QI Chicken Parm
Family Style-
Quality Chicken Parm
Arugula, House Toppings
$68
-
Brunch Parm "alla Carbonara"
Maple Braised Bacon, Fried Eggs, Calabrian Chili
$72
-
"DOP" Chicken Parm
Casella's Proscuitto Speciale, Parmigiano Reggiano
$88
For the Table
Served with our Sesame Foccacia-
Housemade Battenkill Ricotta
Sicilian Oregano Flower Honey & Pine Nuts
$17
-
Our Signature Guac Genovese
Avocado & Pistachio Pesto
$22
-
Casella's Prosciutto Speciale
Hurleyville, New York
$24
PASTA FRESCA
-
Bucatini & Clams
Pepperoni Ragu, Shishito, Crispy Potato
$32
-
Corn Gnudi
Pistachio, Pecorino, Basil
$29
-
Buckwheat Spaghetti alla Chitarra
Braised Bacon, Poached Egg
$21
QI CLASSICS
-
Filet Mignon (10oz)
$49
-
QI Rib Steak (24oz)
w/ a Fried Egg & Breakfast Potatoes +$3
$62
-
Lemon-Charred Chicken Alan
$22
-
The QI Burger
$22
-
Grilled Branzino
$42
SIDES $13
-
Grilled Broccoli Rabe
Crispy Pancetta
Tuscan Fries
Corn Creme Brulee
Italian Breakfast Potatoes
GELATO
-
A Dressed Up Scoop To Go
$9
-
By the Pint
$10
-
Humour Me Strawberry Shortcake
Piña Colada
Burnt Marshmallow Stracciatella
Ferrero Rocher
Agua Fresca
COFFEE SERVICE
-
Espresso
$5.20
-
Macchiato
$5.25
-
Cappuccino
$6.75
-
Brewed Coffee
$4.75
TEA SERVICE $5
-
English Breakfast
-
Genmaicha
-
White Basil-Lemon
-
Mint-Chamomile
GELATO $9
-
Humour Me
Our Take On the Strawberry Shortcake“Good Humor” Bar
-
PIÑA COLADA
Roasted Pineapples, Basil Granita, Pine Nuts
-
BURNT MARSHMALLOW STRACCIATELLA
Graham Cracker Pizzelle, Smoked Meringue
-
Ferrero Rocher
Milk Chocolate & Hazelnut Cream, Crispy Wafer, Candied Hazelnuts
-
AGUA FRESCA
Cucumber Lemon Sorbetto, Pickled Watermelon
DOLCE $12
-
The Hazelnut S'more
Burnt Marshmallow Gelato
-
Tortoni
Almond Semifreddo, Poached Apricots, Salted Pistachios
-
Cannoli Cart
Prepared Tableside, $4 each
-
Chocolate Banana Caramel Bomba
Hazelnut Cream, Chocolate Sponge, Meringue
$22
HOUSEMADE AFTER DINNERS $12
-
Citrus 'Cello
Classic Limone
Clementine & Elderflower
Key Lime, Basil & Cream
-
Corrected Grappa
Café Coretto Style
-
Dry Infused Sambuca
A classic digestif created in house using our unique dry infused method
COFFEE SERVICE
Quality Italian proudly serves City of Saints “Dark Chocolate Roasted Marshmallow Blend” Coffee and Nespresso Espresso beverages.-
Espresso
$5.25
-
Macchiato
$5.25
-
Cappuccino
$5.50
-
Brewed Coffee
$4.75
TEA SERVICE $5
By Tealogist, an artisanal NYC-based company.-
English Breakfast
-
Mint-Chamomile
-
White Basil-Lemon
-
Genmaicha
DESSERT WINE SELECTION
-
Elvio Cogno 2016 Moscato d’Asti, Piedmont
$13
$50
-
Maculan 2012 “ Torcolato” Passito Veneto
$18
$75
-
Dolce by Far Niente 2011 Late Harvest Napa
$29
$125
PORT SELECTION
-
Fonseca 2011 “LBV” Late Bottled Vintage
$15
$95
-
Taylor Fladgate 20 Year “Tawny”
$18
$140
-
Dow’s 2003 Vintage
$29
$230
The wine list at Quality Italian features over 325 bottles from around the world, with a focus on Italian, American and French vintages. And, in keeping with the Italian-American genre of the restaurant, the list features a page dedicated to Italian varietals crafted or produced stateside, like the Barboursville Reserve 2009 Nebbiolo from Virginia and the Palmina 2011 Malvasia from Santa Barbara County.
Quality Italian also features two house-blended wine offerings for guests to enjoy. The Quality Italian “Sonoma-Tuscan” created in partnership with Claus Jenzen and the illustrious Bacio Divino Winery in Napa Valley. This Super-Tuscan styled blend from California features Sangiovese as the dominant grape, providing fresh fruit notes that are rounded out with Petite Sirah and Cabernet Sauvignon for power. The Quality Prosecco was specially crafted by internationally renowned producers, Drusian, offering a fresh and flowery fragrance and fruity palate.
Download PDFWine By The Glass
SPARKLING-
Pasqua Prosecco NV Spumante
Veneto, IT
$13
-
Fantinel "One and Only" 2017 Brut Rosé
Friuli, IT
$19
-
Moët-Chandon “Imperial” NV Brut
Champagne, FR
$24
-
Ruinart Rosé NV Brut (Half Bottle)
Champagne, France
$100
-
Caposaldo 2018 Pinot Grigio
Veneto, IT
$13
-
Planeta “La Segreta Bianco” 2017 Grecanico Blend
Sicily, IT
$15
-
Sella & Mosca “La Cala” 2018 Vermentino
Sardinia, Italy
$16
-
Qupé, "Y Block" 2016 Chardonnay
Santa Barbara, CA
$18
-
Lilou 2018 Sauvignon Blanc
Loire Valley, FR
$19
-
Mer Soleil "Reserve" 2016 Chardonay
Santa Lucia Highlands, CA
$27
-
Anne-Brigitte 2018
Languedoc, FR
$15
-
Madrarossa “Costa Dune” 2017 Nero d’Avola
Sicily, Italy
$13
-
Tenuta di Arceno 2015 Chianti Classic
Tuscany, IT
$16
-
Michele Chiarlo “Le Orme” 2016 Barbera d’Asti
Piedmont, IT
$17
-
Quality Wine 2016 Cabernet Blend
Médoc, Bordeaux, FR
$18
-
Copain "Tous Ensemble" 2016 Pinot Noir
Sonoma Coast
$22
-
Coppo 2012 Barolo
Piedmont, IT
$26
-
Poggio Salvi 2013 Brunello di Montalcino
Tuscany, IT
$29
-
Quilt by Caymus 2016 Cabernet Sauvignon (Poured from Magnum)
Napa
$30
Hand Crafted Cocktails $16
Cocktails at Quality Italian created by Head Barman Bryan Schneider, who joins the team having worked at several top cocktail dens including Monkey Bar and Brooklyn’s Clover Club.-
Agrumi Smash
Ketel One, Citrus Mustarda & Mint
-
A Midtown
Maker's Mark, Housemade Vermouth, Burnt Sugar & Sour Cherry
-
Witch's Britches
Bombay Sapphire, Strega, Fresh Pressed Apple, Honey, Allspice
-
The 57 Spritz
Aperol, Fresh Pressed Grapefruit, Prosecco & Pomegranate Molasses
-
Tricolore Margarita
El Tesoro Platinum, Fresh Lime, Calabrian Chili-Infused Honey, Served Over a Tricolore Cube
-
Quality Cup
Kettle One, Barolo Chinato, Fresh Strawberry
-
Crowd Pleaser
St~Germain, La Croix, Perry's Tot Gin, Fresh Lime
-
Pitcher of Negroni $45
Campari, Cinzano 1857 Vermouth, Your Choice of Dry Gin
Spirits
-
Chambord
Galliano
Baileys
Remy Martin VSOP, XO
Rhubarb Tea
Pimms
Amaretto di Saranno
B&B
Grand Marnier
Drambuie
Sambuca / Black
Aperol
Remy Louis XIII
Cynar
Cocchi Americano
Antica Formula
Chartreuse
Crème de Casis
Frangelico
Harvey's Bristol Cream
Luxardo Maraschino
Luxardo Amaretto
Limoncello Pallini
Pernod Absinthe
Campari
Laubaude Armagnac 1985
Laubaude Armagnac 1980
Cherry Heering
Hennessy VSOP
Rum
-
Diplimatico Reserva
Bacardi Superior
Goslings
Owney’s
Ron Zacapa 23yr
Ron Zacapa XO
JM Rhum VSOP
Cana Brava
Vodka
-
Tito's
Hophead
Stoli Elit
Stoli
Belvedere
Absolut Elyx
Absolut
Grey Goose
Ketel One
Tequila/Mezcal
-
Casa Dragones Platinum
Avion Silver
Cabeza Silver
Patron Silver
Patron Anejo
Casaamigos Reposado
Fortaleza Blanca
Del Maguey "Vida" Mezcal
Don Amado Anejo Mezcal
Gin
-
Hendricks
Tanquaray
Bombay Sapphire East
Ford’s
Greenhook Ginsmith
Plymouth
Beefeater
Old Raj
Perry's Tot Navy Stregnth
Cocktails on Tap $16
-
Quality Mule
Tito's Vodka, House Made Ginger Beer, Lime
-
Nitro Negroni
Campari Negroni Served from a Nitro Faucet
Draught Beer
-
Peroni Lager
Rome, Italy
$8
-
Southern Tier “Right-O-Way” Session IPA
Lakewood, NY
$9
BOTTLES
CRAFT-
Eviltwin Brewing “Falco" IPA
Brooklyn, IPA
$11
-
Cigar City “Maduro” Brown Ale
Tampa, Florida
$10
-
Mikkeller “California Dream” Pilsner
San Diego, California
$11
-
Argus Cidery “Ciderkin”
Austin, Texas
$10
-
Owl’s Brew “ The Blondie” Wheat Beer & Tea
Stevens Point, Wisconsin
$10
-
Baladin “Issac” Wheat Bear Ale
Piozzo, Italy
$11
-
Amstel Light Lager
Zoeterwoude, Netherlands
$7
-
Heineken Lager
Zeoterwoude, Netherlands
$7
-
Budweiser Lager
St. Louis, Missouri
$7
Amaro
-
Averna
Montenegro
Nonino
Cynar
Cardamaro
Lucano
Fernet Branca
Strega
St. Agrestis
Nardini
Ramazzotti
Grappa
-
Mila Chamomile
Zenato Amarone
Nardini Bianca
Clear Creek Distillery Grappa Pinot Gris
Castellare
Candolini Bianca
Nonino
Whiskey
-
Hibiki Japenese Harmony
Nikka 15 yr
George Dickel Barrel Select
Jack Daniels
Green Spot Irish
Canadian Club 12
Jameson
Middleton Irish
Scotch
-
A.D. Rattray 18/20
Aberlour 16
Bowmore 18
Balvenie 12
Craigellache 13
Chivas Regal 12
Chivas Regal 18
Chivas Regal 25
Dahlwinnie 15
Dalmore 12
Dalwhinnie 12
Dewar's White Label
Glenlivet 12
Glenlivet 15
Glenlivet 18
Lagavulin 16
Laphraoig 10
Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban 12
Bourbon & Rye
-
Henry McKenna 10 yr
Woodford Reserve
Bulleit 10 yr
Citrus Noble Small Batch
Rittenhouse Rye
Templeton Rye
Whistle Pig Rye
Ragtime Rye
Sazerac Rye
Mitcher's Rye
Basil Hayden's
Blanton's
Booker's
Hill Rock
Knob Creek
Maker’s Mark
SNACKS $4
-
Sambuca Olives
-
Campari Nuts
COFFEE SERVICE
Quality Italian proudly serves City of Saints “Dark Chocolate Roasted Marshmallow Blend” Coffee and Nespresso Espresso Beverages.-
Espresso
$5.20
-
Macchiato
$5.25
-
Cappuccino
$6.75
-
Brewed Coffee
$4.75
TEA SERVICE
By Brew Lab Tea, an artisanal NYC-based company. $5-
English Breakfast
-
Genmaicha
-
White Basil-Lemon
-
Mint- chamomile
QUALITY SGROPPINO
Housemade Sorbet blended with Vodka & Proecco Classic Lemon/ Cucumber Mint/ Strawberry Black Pepper / Blood Orange Creamsicle / Chili Lime Mango-
* Full Menu Available in Standing Room.
COCKTAILS ON TAP $16
-
Nitro Negroni
Gin, Campari, Carpano Antica, Served from a Nitro Faucet
-
Quality Mule
Vodka, House-made Ginger Beer
BEER
-
Peroni Lager
$8
-
Southern Tier "Right-O-Way"
$9
-
Eviltwin Brewing "Falco"
$11
-
Cigar City "Maduro"
$10
-
Mikkeller "Say Hey Sally"
$11
-
Argus Cidery "Ciderkin"
$10
-
Owl's Brew "The Blondie"
$10
-
Baladin "Isaac"
$11
-
Amstel Light Lager
$7
-
Heineken Lager
$7
-
Budweiser Lager
$7